Comparing Panangin and Cardiomagnyl | Determining the best

0

Author of the article: Marina Dmitrievna

2017.11.04

5 306

Drugs

A lack of potassium and magnesium leads to increased excitability of the pacemaker and muscle cells in the heart. Thus, cardiac arrhythmias arise due to a shift in the membrane potential of cardiomyocytes. At best, only harmless rhythm disturbances (extrasystoles) appear. In severe situations, magnesium or potassium deficiency can lead to dangerous arrhythmias.

Magnesium

Is it possible to take/drink Cardiomagnyl and Panangin at the same time?

Both drugs contain magnesium.
Therefore, it is advisable to take a blood test to check the magnesium content. If it is normal, you can take cardiomagnesium at night, and panangin 3 times a day. Cardiomagnyl - aspirin for thinning the blood. And panangin is used for heart diseases and arrhythmia. Can. Cardiomagnyl contains magnesium and acetylsalicylic acid (aspirin), Panangin contains magnesium and potassium, an analogue of Panangin-Asparkam. The drugs are taken for cardiac arrhythmias and cardiovascular diseases.

Panangin is taken three times a day, Cardiomagnyl once a day and, at best, at night.

Cardiomagnyl is prescribed for the prevention of thrombus formation in cardiovascular diseases.

By thinning the blood, cardiomagnyl fulfills its purpose. The composition contains acetylsalicylic acid and magnesium.

Panangin will also be prescribed for heart diseases. Potassium has a positive effect on the heart. Prescribed for convulsive syndrome, arrhythmias. The composition also contains magnesium, as in cardiomagnyl.

Often both drugs are prescribed at the same time. If cardiomagnyl should be taken on an almost constant basis, then panangin is prescribed in courses.

If you don’t overdo it with panagin and don’t drink more than prescribed, then there will be no overdose of magnesium.

You can drink Cardiomagnyl and Panangin at the same time.

Manufacturers

The main differences between these two drugs are their manufacturers and price.

Panangin is produced only by pharmaceuticals (Hungary).

Asparkam is produced by many domestic and foreign companies, such as Biosintez OJSC (Russia), Zdorovye (Ukraine), Medisorb (Russia), Pharmstandard-Leksredstva (Russia), Marbiofarm (Russia), Medisorb (Russia), etc.

On average, panangin tablets or ampoules are 2–3 times more expensive than similar asparkam preparations.

Hungarian pharmaceutical company Gedeon Richter

So which is better - asparkam or panangin? Among the medical community, there is an opinion that of these two drugs, panangin deserves more trust. However, there have been no scientific studies comparing the effectiveness and safety of these drugs.

The composition of both drugs is almost identical, and the active ingredients are simple chemical compounds. That is, there cannot be large differences in pharmacological and pharmacodynamic properties between them. Therefore, many doctors still believe that these drugs should be identical.

Why do doctors give preference to panangin? The point is greater trust in the European manufacturer and the quality control that it uses. Some doctors even believe that domestic companies producing asparkam are not entirely conscientious about the production of medicines, so the actual composition of this drug may not correspond to the declared one.

Patients with various pathologies of the heart and blood vessels are prescribed drugs containing magnesium and potassium in complex therapy. The question often arises about which is better - Asparkam or Panangin. It is impossible to answer this question unequivocally, because each drug has its own characteristics. To understand how both medications act on the body and try to figure out which one is better, you should conduct a comparative analysis.

Cardiomagnyl and Panangin, what is the difference?

Cardiomagnyl is a drug that performs an antiaggregation (prevents platelet aggregation) function.

Panangin is a medicine that replenishes the lack of potassium and magnesium ions in the body, and also has an antiarrhythmic (prevents heart rhythm disturbances) function.

• Cardiomagnyl - the main active ingredients in this drug are acetylsalicylic acid and magnesium hydroxide. Additionally, the composition includes substances necessary to give the optimal pharmacological form.
• Panangin - the main components in this preparation are magnesium and potassium aspartates. The composition also contains additional substances necessary to provide an optimal release form.

Mechanism of action

• Cardiomagnyl - this drug prevents the formation of thromboxane (a substance involved in blood clotting), thereby preventing the adhesion of blood cells (platelets and red blood cells) and the formation of a blood clot (mural blood clot). The drug also reduces the surface tension of the red blood cell membrane, due to which it passes through the capillary faster, increasing the rheological (fluidity) properties of the blood.
• Panangin - this medicine replenishes magnesium and potassium ions, which are necessary for the normal functioning of the body (digestive processes, contractions of the heart muscle). Due to the presence of the aspartic form of ions, which act as a conductor of the substance into the cell, magnesium and potassium penetrate the membrane faster, thereby accelerating the process of restoring electrolyte balance.

• Prevention of cardiovascular diseases (heart attack, thrombosis);
• Prevention of the formation of thromboembolism (blockage of a large vessel with a blood clot) after extensive surgery (surgery on the chest, abdominal cavity);
• After operations on varicose veins (removal and excision of sections of the vein);
• Unstable angina (the period between coronary heart disease and the development of myocardial infarction).

• Chronic heart failure;
• Post-infarction period;
• Heart rhythm disturbances (ventricular and atrial arrhythmias);
• In combination with therapy with cardiac glycosides (medicines taken for arrhythmias);
• Lack of magnesium and potassium in food.

Contraindications

• Individual intolerance to the components of the drug;
• Stroke (bleeding in the brain);
• Bleeding disorders (hemophilia) and tendency to bleed;
• Ulcerative lesions of the stomach and duodenum;
• Bleeding from the gastrointestinal tract (gastrointestinal tract);
• Bronchial asthma;
• Pregnancy and breastfeeding period;
• Age (not prescribed to children under 18 years of age);
• Kidney and liver failure.

• Individual intolerance to the components of the drug;
• Kidney and liver failure;
• Excess potassium and magnesium in the body (hyperkalemia and hypermagnesemia);
• Atrioventricular block (impaired conduction of impulses in the heart);
• Arterial hypotension (low blood pressure);
• Myasthenia gravis (a disease characterized by rapid fatigue of the striated muscles);
• Hemolysis of red blood cells (destruction of red blood cells and release of hemoglobin);
• Metabolic acidosis (increased levels of acids in the blood);
• Pregnancy and breastfeeding period.

Side effects

• Allergic reactions (redness, rash and itching of the skin);
• Dyspeptic symptoms (nausea, vomiting, bloating, flatulence and abdominal pain);
• Gastrointestinal bleeding;
• Intracerebral hemorrhage;
• Anemia (decrease in the number of blood cells);
• Bleeding gums;
• Headaches, dizziness;
• Insomnia.

• Allergic reactions;
• Dyspeptic symptoms;
• Extrasystole (extraordinary heart contractions);
• Paresthesia (stiffness of movements);
• Reduced blood pressure;
• Respiratory depression;
• Thirst;
• Cramps.

Comparative composition analysis

Potassium and magnesium are important for the normal functioning of all human organs and systems. The pharmacological properties of Panangin and Asparkam are ensured precisely thanks to these microelements. The table shows the composition of both medications.

The table shows that the number of main active components of both products is absolutely identical. The only difference is in the excipients. Additional components do not affect the effect of the drug, so we can conclude that the pharmacological effect of the drugs is the same.

Panangin or Cardiomagnyl - which is better?

This question cannot be answered unambiguously, since these drugs belong to different pharmacological groups. Cardiomagnyl and Panangin also differ in their indications, contraindications and side effects. What these drugs have in common is the presence of magnesium in the composition.

Cardiomagnyl is used to prevent thrombus formation and prevent such pathologies (diseases): myocardial infarction, thromboembolism of large vessels.

Panangin is prescribed in cases of lack of magnesium and potassium in the body, as well as for heart diseases associated with a lack of these ions (arrhythmia, myocardial ischemia). There is a release form of Panangin forte, which differs from classic Panangin in a large amount of active substance (Panagnin - magnesium 140 mg, potassium 160 mg, forte - magnesium 280 mg, potassium - 316 mg).

Is there a need to constantly take medications?

Some people take Panangin or Cardiomagnyl without prescription in order to protect the heart from dangerous diseases, but according to WHO warnings this is not advisable. On the contrary, uncontrolled use of Cardiomagnyl and Panangin can lead to an excess of microelements in the body or provoke serious side effects.

The use of drugs containing these elements is indicated only when their deficiency in the blood is detected. In some situations, under the supervision of a doctor, it is allowed to take Panangin and Cardiomagnyl simultaneously.

Panangin and Cardiomagnyl - can they be taken together?

Many people are interested in the question: is it possible to take Cardiomagnyl and Panangin at the same time? In small doses, it is possible to take drugs together; Cardiomagnyl will prevent blood clots, and Panangin will replenish the balance of ions. With proper combined use of medications, the risk of recurrent myocardial infarction, vascular thrombosis, and other cardiac pathologies will be significantly reduced. It is necessary to drink Kadiomagnil and Panangin according to the instructions of the attending physician, in order to avoid the development of side effects.

Contraindications

Panangin and its analogue Asparkam are prohibited for the treatment of patients with cardiac pathologies in the following situations:

• development of urinary retention;
• excess potassium, magnesium in human blood;
• severe kidney pathologies;
• dehydration;
• increased blood acidity levels;
• muscular myasthenia.

Despite the fact that both products are sold in pharmacies without a prescription and have a natural composition, it is recommended to consult a doctor before using one or the other drug.

Similarities between the compositions of Panangin and Cardiomagnyl

Cardiomagnyl is prescribed for vascular therapy. The active ingredients are magnesium hydroxide and aspirin. The medicine improves blood circulation and eliminates thrombosis.

The drug has an effective effect on ischemia, vascular insufficiency, cerebral hemorrhages, and varicose veins. The product protects the lining of the stomach from the negative effects of acid.

Indications for use of this drug:

1. Prevention of heart pathologies and heart attacks.
2. Reducing blood cholesterol.
3. After vascular surgery.
4. Prevention of thromboembolism.
5. Normalization of the central nervous system.

Cardiomagnyl treats heart disease, prevents the development of myocardial infarction and thromboembolism. The drug is contraindicated for diseases of the digestive system, asthma, intolerance to the components of the drug, poor blood clotting, children, pregnant and lactating women.

Cardiomagnyl also has anti-inflammatory and analgesic properties, and lowers temperature. The drug is taken for 1-2 months, then a break is taken, then treatment is continued. Cardiomagnyl is produced in tablets.

Panangin contains active ingredients - potassium and magnesium, they stabilize the functioning of the heart.

The medicine is recommended to eliminate ischemia and vascular dystonia. The drug is also prescribed to eliminate muscle cramps and improve the functioning of the heart muscle.

The active component magnesium aspartate, as an endogenous substance, is a carrier of potassium and magnesium ions, has a pronounced affinity for cells, its salts undergo dissociation only slightly. As a result, ions penetrate into the intracellular space. Panangin improves the metabolism of the heart muscle.

Indications for use of Panangin:

• heart failure;
• myocardial infarction and blood vessel thrombosis;
• arrhythmia.

Contraindications to the use of the drug:

• renal dysfunction;
• excess magnesium and potassium;
• dehydration;
• pregnancy;
• lactation.

Adverse reactions: nausea, vomiting, heaviness in the abdomen. Panangin is produced in the form of tablets and solution for injections. Tablets are taken 3 times a day after meals, 1-2 pieces.

Characteristics of Panangin

The therapeutic effect of the drug is based on the combined action of 2 active compounds - potassium and magnesium in the form of aspartates. Mineral components help stabilize heart rate. Thanks to regular use of the drug, magnesium and potassium deficiency does not develop in the body, and metabolism in the cells of the heart muscle is not disrupted. Ions of chemical elements restore myocardial contractility.

It is important to remember that a lack of mineral components can lead to a number of metabolic disorders. Metabolic failure can provoke the development of atherosclerosis of the vascular walls of the coronary arteries and hypertension. This does not happen when taking Panangin.

There are the following indications for taking the drug:

• ventricular arrhythmias;
• ischemic disease;
• post-infarction period;
• magnesium and potassium deficiency;
• muscle cramps;
• heart failure.

When treating with Panangin, the drug is used 1-2 tablets 3 times a day. In rare cases, when the medication is abused, signs of gastrointestinal disorders and allergic reactions appear.

The drug is contraindicated in the following cases:

• Addison's disease;
• renal failure;
• excess potassium and magnesium in the body;
• myasthenia gravis;
• atrioventricular block;
• individual intolerance to structural components;
• acute metabolic disorder.

When treating with Panangin, the drug is used 1-2 tablets 3 times a day.

The drug is available in 2 dosage forms: tablets and a solution for injection. In the latter case, for intravenous administration, the medicine must be dissolved in 50 or 100 ml of glucose solution.

Differences between Panangin and Cardiomagnyl

Both medications are for heart therapy, but they have different compositions. Both contain magnesium. Therefore, medications have different effects. Panangin contains a large amount of magnesium, which is necessary for the heart.

The negative reactions of both drugs are the same: nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, flatulence. Cardiomagnyl eliminates thrombosis, and Panangin is used to improve heart function. Medicines can be prescribed together as part of complex therapy. Which medication is best is determined by the attending physician.

Conditions for dispensing from pharmacies

Both drugs are available in pharmacies without a prescription.

The price of the drug Panangin in pharmacies is:

• tablets, 50 pcs. made in Hungary - 137 rubles;
• tablets with Vitamin B6, 545 mg, 60 pcs. (Hungary) - 310 rubles;
• ampoules 10 ml, 5 pcs. (Hungary) - 153 rubles;
• Forte tablets, 60 pcs. (Hungary) - 341 rub.

The cost of the drug Cardiomagnyl (tablets) in pharmacies is:

• 75+15.2 mg, 100 pcs. (Russia) - 207 rubles;
• 150 mg+30.39 mg, 100 pcs. (Japan) - 350 rubles;
• 75+15.2 mg, 30 pcs. (Japan) price 121 rub;
• 150 mg+30.39 mg, 30 pcs. (Japan) - 198 rub.

Reviews from doctors about Panangin and Cardiomagnyl

Victor Terentyevich, oncologist

Cardiomagnyl is used in clinical practice to prevent cancer of the gastrointestinal tract. This is explained by the fact that the medicine is able to eliminate free radicals in cells.

Taisiya Sergeevna, cardiologist

Both drugs are prescribed for the treatment of heart disease, to prevent myocardial infarction and thromboembolism. Panangin is a safer remedy because has fewer adverse reactions than Cardiomagnyl. But long-term treatment increases the risk of hyperkalemia. These medications are used to treat vascular pathologies only as prescribed by a doctor.

Vera Nikolaevna, therapist

These pharmaceuticals are prescribed together only in small doses. Exceeding the dose leads to adverse reactions: bleeding, abdominal pain, drowsiness. During treatment, you must strictly follow the dosages prescribed by your doctor.

Mikhail Nikolaevich, neurologist

In the practice of treating patients, these medications are often prescribed to normalize blood circulation in the brain. They supply brain tissue with oxygen and glucose and help improve the condition of patients.

Patient reviews

Natalya, 37 years old

Recently, periodic pain in the heart area and shortness of breath have appeared. By evening these symptoms intensified. I went to the doctor. After the examination, the doctor prescribed Panangin. This is a good remedy, it helped, shortness of breath and heart pain disappeared, and my general condition improved.

Gleb, 38 years old

I go in for sports, lead an active lifestyle, I have never complained about my health before, but recently I began to notice increased fatigue, poor health, heaviness in the chest and shortness of breath. To prevent heart disease, the doctor prescribed Panangin. This is an excellent tool. After completing the course, the condition improved, shortness of breath and discomfort in the chest disappeared.

Valentina, 32 years old

For the treatment of arrhythmia, the doctor prescribed Cardiomagnyl. I took it every day, 1 tablet in the morning and evening. After completing the course of treatment, the condition returned to normal, and arrhythmia is no longer observed. This is an excellent drug, I recommend it to everyone.

Tatyana Ivanovna, 58 years old

I have been suffering from ischemia for several years; to prevent heart attack and thrombosis, I regularly take these drugs as prescribed by my attending physician; they work well and have no side effects. After therapy I feel better. The simultaneous use of the described drugs increases their effectiveness.